A valuable home still has to house you.
Selling your home may require buying elsewhere or paying rent. Assess its value alongside the mortgage and housing need before assigning the proceeds to another goal.
A home, job and rental flat in one city can depend on the same economy. Another building can deepen that dependence; the whole-wealth assessment includes what you own outside investment accounts.
What remains from the rent?
Potential rent €12,000 → collected €11,000
Dashed: €1,000 never received during vacancy.
Collected €11,000 → retained €7,000
Hatched: €4,000 paid in operating expenses.
€12,000 − €1,000 − €4,000 = €7,000.
Gross yield 6%; retained cash 3.5%: not a complete return.
Now include a fall to €180,000
Same year and other exclusions; cash +€7,000, price −€20,000.
Combined −€13,000 (−6.5%). Rent only offsets part of the price loss.
What the rental example leaves out
MoneyHelper highlights vacancies, repairs and continuing mortgage payments. Its lending/tax details are UK-specific, not a typical margin or complete after-tax return.
The debt does not shrink with the building’s price.
Before: €200,000 = €150,000 debt + €50,000 equity
After: €180,000 = €150,000 debt + €30,000 equity
Hatched debt stays fixed. The €20,000 fall comes out of equity: 40% of the owner's initial €50,000.
Mortgage payments remain due. An appraisal does not supply an immediate buyer; selling takes time and costs money.
The work and costs outside the equity calculation
Beyond the excluded taxes, repayments and financing cash flows, tenants, repairs, records and legal duties require work even with an agent. Sale negotiations, disposal costs and timing affect the money released.
Listed shares and non-traded property are different routes.
Property-owning and mortgage-focused REITs have different businesses. Listed shares delegate operations but can fall or concentrate in a region/property type. A REIT fund adds holdings and costs.
Non-traded vehicles may restrict redemption and use periodic appraisals. Distributions can include returned capital or borrowing rather than earnings. These SEC examples concern US structures; local tax status, eligibility, disclosure and distribution rules vary. A quoted distribution rate is not a universal after-tax return.
Does another holding change the household’s dependence?
Include your home, debts and REITs already inside share funds. Direct property, listed REITs and non-traded vehicles offer different control, access and work. None guarantees an offset to losses elsewhere. A dedicated allocation needs a missing role, not merely another building or fund name.